 |

Return to the: DNR Homepage or Type 5 Stream Literature Review (main DNR site)
What
specific Type 5 stream structures or functions should be protected to
meet department management goals?
Statements within this literature review are based on the reported findings from various published sources. Due to differences in sample design, methodology, geographical location, site characteristics, data analysis and interpretation, these statements may or may not agree with the results of other published reports. Despite contradictory results, one cannot say the findings of one author are more or less valid than another, due to the wide range of site characterists. Readers are urged to consider how and where information was collected when interpreting the value of the following conclusions. Headwater stream science is, in many ways, a relatively new field. Early observations and case studies may or may not represent widespread relationships.
Click on the citation following each statement to view the annotated bibliography
- The Rhyacophila
fenderi, Lepidostoma jewetti, Rhyacophila grandis,
Psychoglypha avigo, Dolophilodes sisko, Pseudostenophylax
edwarsi, and Wormaldia occidea utilized the temporary
streams by synchronizing their growth period to the wet season, inhabiting
seeps, and/or dispersing to permanent streams. (Anderson
and Dieterich 1993).
- The abundance, taxa
richness, and community composition of hyporheic epibenthic populations
was greatest in first order streams and decreased with increasing
stream order.
(Angradi 2001).
- Temperatures increase
faster in smaller channels than larger channels. (Beechie
et al. 2000).
- The breakdown rates
of tree leaves is faster in catchments that have been logged than
in catchments that are forested. The author speculates that there
are fewer retentive obstacles in the logged catchments, so the leaves
move more quickly during high flows, contributing to faster breakdown
rates. (Benfield
et al. 1991).
- Debris dams hold
up to 75% of the organic material in first order streams. This percentage
decreases to 58% in second order streams, and 20% in third order streams.
The low discharge rate of smaller streams can explain the high percentage
of organic matter retention behind debris dams. (low energy = increased
dam formation). (Bilby
and Likens 1980).
- Within streams less
than 7 m wide, 40% of the wood was oriented perpendicular to the stream
flow. However, in larger streams woody debris was oriented parallel
to the stream flow. (Bilby
and Ward 1989).
- In small streams,
42% of the pools were plunge pools, and 40% of the in-stream wood
accumulated sediment and organic material. (Bilby
and Ward 1989).
- Sediment and organic
matter accumulates behind in-stream wood more frequently in small
streams, than in larger streams. (Bilby
and Ward 1989).
- Marsh water temperatures
were significantly warmer than spring source points. (Black
2001).
- Hyporheic water temperatures
were higher in the pasture sites than in the forested sites. (Boulton
et al. 1997).
- The native forest
had a diverse invertebrate fauna composed mostly of surface benthos,
which were not present in the pasture hyporheic zones. (Boulton
et al. 1997).
- Type 4 streams with
no buffer were 2 - 8 degrees warmer than the non-harvested streams.
After harvest, brush and slash provided 40% of the shade for the Type
4 streams without buffers. This study concluded that the downstream
effect from small streams to larger streams is limited to 150m beyond
the Type 4 stream. (Caldwell
et al. 1991).
- This study found
30m buffers effective for retaining small mammal populations (with
the exception of Microtus oregoni (Creeping Vole)). In comparison
to the control streams, the clearcut/no buffer sites had much lower
populations of Sorex monticolus (dusky shrews), and Clethrionomys
gappari (red backed voles). The researchers found an increased
rate of bot fly infestation of small mammals in the unbuffered zones.
Captures in the controls had no infestation, while animals in the
30m buffered zone had an intermediate rate of infestation. (Cockle
et al. 2003).
- Logging in high gradient
streams increases the amount of slash within the channel, therefore
increasing the potential for organic dams to form. (Coho
and Burges 1994).
- Type 4 and 5 streams
are the most common places for dam formation. (Coho
and Burges 1994).
- Timber harvest increases
the densities of "disturbance tolerant" macroinvertebrates;
such as Sphaeriidae, Cammaridae, and Chironomidae
species. Concurrently, overall macroinvertebrate diversity is decreased
after timber harvest. This is contrary to the lower distribution of
"disturbance tolerant" species in mature forest stands.
(Cole
et al. 2003).
- Annual litter input
declines with greater stream order (the smaller the stream the greater
the litter input). (Connors
and Naiman 1984).
- The hyporheic zone
in intermittent streams is not a refuge for invertebrates during the
dry season. (Del
Rosario and Resh 2000).
- Intermittent stream
fauna have a lower total density, taxon richness, and species diversity
than perennial streams. The hyporheic resident invertebrates were
unchanged (Sweltsa spp.) or decreased (Baetis, Parthina,
Ceratopogonidae spp.), but densities of a permanent hyporheic
resident (Archianelida spp.) increased during the drying
period. The hyporheic fauna in the intermittent streams have lower
densities, similar richness, but higher diversity of invertebrate
species than perennial streams. (Del
Rosario and Resh 2000).
- In perennial streams
the invertebrates move downstream with the drift, and the flow. In
temporary streams the invertebrates move upstream, and vertically
downward toward the hyporheic zone. (Delucchi
1989).
- Permanent streams
displayed larger temperature fluctuations than temporary streams.
(Dieterich 1993).
- Temporary streams
have a high retentiveness feature. They have large quantities of allochthonous
material despite low input. (Dieterich
1993).
- Ephemeral streams
filter out fine sediment from the water column that is delivered from
roads. When there is a high level of precipitation, the channel floods
and quickly widens. This flooding process filters the fine sediment
through the soil rather than transporting it downstream. (Dieterich
1993).
- Temporary and ephemeral
streams channel nitrate from the surface water to the groundwater.
(Dieterich
1993).
- A large portion of
the temporary stream fauna is composed of facultative species. These
species are specially adapted, and have drought resistant life-stages
that respond to different moisture conditions. (Dieterich
1993).
- Invertebrate richness,
and diversity can decrease in summer-dry streams, if flow duration,
and habitat availability decreases. (Dieterich
1993).
- Summer-dry streams
have obligate stream species, such as Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera,
and Trichoptera. It would be uncommon to find these species
as obligate species in other parts of the world with unpredictable
climatic patterns. (Dieterich
1993).
- Mayflies and stoneflies
exhibit prolonged hatching periods, and a asynchronous developmental
life-stage in temporary streams. (Dieterich
and Anderson 1995).
- Ephemeral streams
dry out very rapidly, leaving a few seeps, and retaining water for
longer periods. The temporary streams loose water gradually, and about
5% of the overall channel is permanently wet, often with seeps, and
pool habitats. (Dieterich
and Anderson 1998).
- Ephemeral streams
retain fine sediment from roads and/or timber harvest, and incorporate
it into larger sediment into the soil, which is then held by plants
or grasses that grow during the dry season. (Dieterich
and Anderson 1998).
- Summer-dry streams
have the capability to remove nitrate from the water column. (Dieterich
and Anderson 1998).
- 45% of the invertebrate
species found in the forested streams occurred in summer seeps and
pools. (Dieterich
and Anderson 2000).
- Temporary forested
streams have a 20% greater species richness than was found in permanent
streams. The author speculated that this may be due to several of
the following factors; the close proximity to refugia, reduced predator
pressure, and less competition from snails or other competitors. (Dieterich
and Anderson 2000)
- Even with the installation
of buffers, air temperatures increased significantly in the riparian
and upland zones. The results of this paper indicate that a 70m buffer
strip is not enough to protect from increased air temperatures. (Dong
et al. 1998).
- The models developed during this study show that a 4°C increase in air temperature, will decrease relative humidity exponentially from 94% to about 77%. Conversely, vapor pressure deficit budgets increase exponentially. This may damage amphibian, moss, and lichen populations, which are dependent on vaporized water throughout their life cycles. (Dong
et al. 1998).
- Small ephemeral streams
store fine sediments washed from the road surface. In-stream woody
debris also traps, and retains sediment. (Duncan
et al. 1987).
- This study found
that ephemeral streams temporarily retain coarser sized sediment (>0.063
mm) washed from the roads. (Duncan
et al 1987).
- High-gradient, ephemeral
streams that flow during rain-on-snow melt tend to have irregular
"steps." Short, low-gradient reaches are interspersed with
longer, high-gradient reaches. Debris accumulates in short, low-gradient
areas. The fluvial movement is pulsed, which guards against build-up
of large amounts of debris, reducing the potential for sudden debris
flows or torrents. (Gardner
1986).
- According to the
authors, riparian zones have greater species richness than uplands
do. Various inventoried stands in western Oregon had twice as many
species in the riparian zone compared to the uplands. (Gregory et
al. 1991).
- Riparian trees and
herbaceous vegetation have extensive root networks that increase bank
stability, and decrease erosion processes. (Gregory et al. 1991).
- Large woody debris
was the primary source of the in-stream barriers that stored sediment.
(Grizzel
and Wolff 1998).
- Water temperature,
and the rate of warming is highly variable in short headwater stream
reaches (<300m). (Hagan
2000).
- Macroinvertebrates
living in first-order streams rely on terrestrial food sources, because
instream algal growth is limited in areas with a closed canopy. Riparian
areas that retain a mix of coniferous and decidious vegetation is
optimal for macroinvertebrates, because coniferous needles alone make
a poor quality food source.
(Haggerty et al. 2002).
- Wood plays an important
role as a microhabitat for invertebrates. A number of taxa were found
inside wood crevices, where they could avoid predation. (Haggerty
et al. 2002).
- Intermittent reaches
had fewer amphibians than the perennial streams. Small torrent salamanders
(Rhyacotriton spp.) inhabited a higher percentage of initiation
reaches, and seeps, possibly using these habitats for reproduction.
(Hayes
and Quinn 2001).
- Tree seedlings are
much less abundant in hardwood dominated stands. (Hibbs
and Bower 2001).
- Hardwoods more frequently
colonize terrace terrains, while conifers more typically occupy slopes.
(Hibbs
and Bower 2001).
- Red alder (Alnus
rubra) and bigleaf maple (Acer macrophyllum) seedlings
were more common on mineral soils, while western hemlock (Tsuga
heterophylla) and Pacific yew (Taxus brevifolia) seedlings
were much more common on woody substrates. (Hibbs
and Bower 2001).
- Geomorphic relationships
for larger streams can not be applied to smaller headwater streams.
Large woody debris (>40cm in diameter) created less than 10% of
the steps formed in headwater channels. The three major step forming
agents in small streams included the following: small wood (between
10-40 cm), inorganic material, and organic debris (<10cm). (Jackson
and Sturm 2001).
- Small streams exhibit
low fluvial movement. (Jackson
and Sturm 2001).
- The most commonly
observed morphological difference in small streams vs. large streams
was the abundance of step-riffles rather than pools. (Jackson
and Sturm 2001).
- The stream temperature in the two clearcut basins increased by seven degrees, which occurred earlier in the summer than in the control basin. The two biggest factors controlling stream temperature were short wave solar radiation, which is amplified after the removal of the riparian vegetation, and the conduction between the stream water and the nearby substrates/soils. The disturbed watersheds returned to pre-harvest temperature levels after 15 years. (Johnson
and Jones 2000).
- Sites where only overstory vegetation was removed generally had smaller increases in stream temperature than where the understory was also removed through burning or herbicide treatments. (Johnson and Jones).
- Dicamptodon tenebrosus
living in buffered streams, behaved similarly to those found in forested
habitats. However, in clearcut areas, this species stays closer to
the stream channel. Consequently, their home ranges are smaller, they
stay in refugia longer, and move more often during rain events. (Johnston
and Frid 2002).
- Besides habitat,
riparian buffers provide shade, bank stability, and continuous inputs
of organic matter. Buffers also reduce runoff, and act as barriers
to logging debris. (Kelsey
and West 2001).
- Berry producing shrubs
should always be retained in the buffer, because they provide an important
food source for many species. (Kelsey
and West 2001).
- Approximately 29%
of riparian wildlife species are classified as riparian obligates,
which means they need riparian habitat to survive. (Kelsey
and West 2001).
- Not only does the
riparian zone provide habitat for wildlife, it also serves as refuge
from predators and as a topographical landmark for navigation (especially
for birds). (Kelsey
and West 2001).
- Riparian systems
support generalists, exotic species, and riparian obligates (which
are mostly amphibians). (Kelsey
and West 2001).
- Bats, beavers, minks,
moles, muskrats, river otters, and many birds regularly inhabit riparian
areas. (Kelsey
and West 2001).
- Forbs, herbs, and
rocks are in greater abundance in the riparian zone. (Kelsey
and West 2001).
- Tailed frogs (Ascaphus
truei) respond negatively to clear cutting, even when buffers
are installed. (Kelsey
and West 2001).
- Coarse particulate
organic matter (CPOM), and fine particulate organic matter (FPOM)
are positively correlated to the daily stream discharge. (Kiffney
et al. 2000).
- Dissolved organic
matter (DOM) is inversely related to discharge (DOM increases as discharge
decreases). (Kiffney
et al. 2000).
- Seasonal and annual
variations in precipitation and stream discharge, can either increase
or decrease the amount of CPOM, FPOM, DOM, and epilithic organic matter
found in the stream.
(Kiffney et al. 2000).
- Anthropogenic barriers,
such as suspended culverts, should be reduced or eliminated to allow
for full dispersal of Oncorhynchus spp. to their natural
distributions. (Latterell
et al. 2003).
- Intermittent streams
located in old-growth forests exhibited the following characteristics:
drying began in May or June, and ended by July; lengthy annual flow
durations; cool and stable stream temperatures; coarse substrates;
streamside vegetation consisting of overstory and understory plants
that are associated with both dry, and wet conditions; and low to
moderate densities of large woody debris. (Lee
1997).
- Intermittent streams
located in young stands exhibited the following characteristics: dry
1-2 months later than the old growth stand, higher daily stream temperatures,
finer substrates, more deciduous and herbaceous understory, and less
moderately decayed large woody debris. (Lee
1997).
- Intermittent streams
were dominated by Rhyacotriton cascadae (Cascade torrent
salamander), and Plethodon dunni (Dunn's salamander). Rhyacotriton
cascadae's were mostly found in shallow, slow moving waters,
and in seeps. Plethodon dunni's were found in seeps,
and along stream banks.
(Lee 1997).
- The intermittent
streams contained mostly larval, and juvenile amphibians. The author
speculates that these streams might be used for rearing habitats.
(Lee 1997).
- Small streams can
serve as large sediment reservoirs in between debris flow periods.
The author suggests that if these small streams are depleted of woody
debris, the sediment storage capacity will greatly decrease, transporting
a chronic source of sediment downstream. (May
2002).
- Woody debris in colluvial channels functioned as sediment storage points (40%), small wood storage (20%), or had no current function at all. (May
and Gresswell 2003).
- Fluvial redistribution
of woody debris is less common in colluvial channels with steep gradients,
because the stream channel lacks the energy necessary to transport
these materials. Therefore, woody debris is stored in small streams
for an extended period of time, and only episodically moves downstream
during catastrophic events, such as debris flows. (May
and Gresswell 2003).
- Small streams without
woody debris, may become chronic sources of sediments to downstream
reaches. (May
and Gresswell 2003).
- In both canopied and uncanopied stream reaches, true flies (Diptera spp.)and mayflies (Ephemeroptera spp.) were the most abundant invertebrates flushed from the stomachs of coho salmon, cutthroat and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus spp. ). (Meehan 1996).
- Large woody debris
is important in maintaining channel integrity and floodplain processes.
(Naiman
et al. 2001).
- Large woody debris
provides sights for colonization by conifer and decidious trees and
shrubs. (Naiman
et al. 2001).
- Coarse woody debris
(CWD) in first- and second-order streams, usually decomposes or fragments into
smaller pieces.
(Nakamura and Swanson 1993).
- Hardwood dominated
riparian areas, were likely to have existed before the onslaught of
forest disturbance in the 19th and 20th centuries. (Nierenberg
and Hibbs 2000).
- Headwater streams can potentially provide breeding habitat for terrestrial amphibians, such as newts (Taricha granulosa) and ensantinas (Ensatina eschscholtzii). (Olson et al. 2000).
- In this study, trout (Oncorhynchus spp.) and Pacific giant salamanders (Dicamptodon tenebrosus) were associated with larger, wetter streams. Conversely, torrent salamanders (Rhyacotriton spp.) were more common in smaller, dryer streams. (Olson et al. 2000).
- Tailed frogs (Ascaphus truei) were found to have a positive association with narrow, discontinuous stream reaches, while Pacific giant salamanders (Dicamptodon tenebrosus) had a negative association with the same habitat type. (Olson et al. 2000).
- All arthropods found in the uplands, were also found in the riparian zone. However the riparian zone had greater arthropod abundance and diversity. This availability of prey species probably contributes to greater near stream amphibian diversity. (Olson et al. 2000).
- Snag structures should
recieve protection during harvest. This can be done by adding "skips"
or leave tree islands into the harvest plan. (Olson
et al. 2002).
- Mycorrhizal relationships and lichen hotspots are important components of diverse forest ecosystems. These resources can be maintained in leave tree islands. (Olson
et al. 2002).
- Headwater streams
remove ammonium from the water column within 10-100 meters. (Peterson
et al. 2001).
- Small streams also
remove nitrate, but it takes 5-10 times longer than the removal of
the ammonium. (Peterson
et al. 2001).
- Lichens that were abundant in riparian hotspots were found much less frequently in adjacent uplands. (Peterson
and McCune 2003).
- Nitrogen-fixing cyanolichens
are associated with riparian hotspots and hardwood trees. (Peterson
and McCune 2003).
- This study found
that Lobaria pulmonaria is more closely associated with hardwoods,
rather than old-growth, as previously believed. (Peterson
and McCune 2003).
- Large woody debris
does not play a role in sediment storage in 1st order streams because
these channels are narrow, which prevents the logs from lying in a
position in which they could store sediment. (Potts
and Anderson 1990).
- First order streams
have a greater number of organic obstructions than are found in third
order streams. The author speculates that third order streams have
a deeper and wider channel limiting the construction of small debris
formations. (Potts
and Anderson 1990).
- Organic debris in intermittent and ephemeral streams, plays an important role in channel stability, and sediment storage . (Potts
and Anderson 1990).
- Species richness
was similar between perennial and intermittent streams, but lower
in ephemeral streams. (Price
et al. 2003)
- Intermittent streams
provide a unique habitat were species have adapted to low-flow periods
and occasional drying. (Price
et al. 2003).
- Macroinvertebrates
of the "shredder" feeding group, were more abundant in smaller
intermittant and ephemeral streams. (Price
et al. 2003).
- Aquatic and terrestrial
amphibians were most abundant in old forests, least abundant in young
forests, and intermediate in mature forests, including buffered and
thinned sites. (Raphael
et al. 2002).
- Amphibians and fish
are most sensitive to physical, instream attributes, such as elevation,
gradient, and bedrock material. (Raphael
et al. 2002).
- Aquatic amphibians
utilize instream coarse woody debris as refuge from predators. (Rundio
et al. 2002).
- Refuge availability
for Dicamptodon species is probably important to avoid
predator/prey interactions with Cutthroat trout. (Rundio
et al. 2002).
- Basalt geology produces
more of the coarse substrates (cobble, gravel) that Rhyacotriton
kezeri species prefer. High gradients are prefered by this species
because fine sediments do not accumulate in the interstitial spaces
between cobble and gravel substrates, where R. kezeri is
often found. (Russell
et al. 2004).
- Resource reduction
inluences invertebrate drift. The treated stream (litter exclusion)
had a lower drift density, but the proportion of benthic animals drifting
was greater. The author concludes that drift may be used as a mechanism
for invertebrates to locate other food resources. (Siler
et al. 2001).
- After harvest,
wood loading along type 5 streams is moderate to high. Most of the
pieces are buried, and/or decayed. (Soicher
1999).
- Key woody debris
pieces provide stability for small streams by creating steps, storing
sediment, and dissipating hydraulic energy. (Soicher
1999).
- Instream large woody
debris provides nutrients, refuge, and a deposition site for organic
matter (food) for aquatic organisms. (Swanson
and Fredriksen 1982).
- This study states that juvenile tailed frogs stay closer to the stream in clearcuts, but adults seemed mostly unaffected by canopy cover. Howerver, juveniles moved farther from the stream in old growth forests, than in clearcuts. This study suggests that tailed frog larvae may initially benefit from clearcut harvesting, but juveniles and adults may not. This is due to impaired land movements which would reduce foraging, and increase competition. (Wahbe et al. 2004).
- Vegetation in the
riparian zone is influenced by "water availability, disturbance
regime, and levels of solar radiation." (Waters
et al. 2001).
- 90% of the small
mammals captured, were taken from the Black Hills sites. 87% of the
amphibians found, were from the Willapa Hills sites. (Wilk
and Raphael 2002).
- Seven species of
shrews were detected. The most common shrews found were Neurotrichus
gibbsii (shrew mole), and Sorex trowbridgii
(Trowbridge's shrew). Four species of amphibians were also found,
the most common one being Rhyacotriton kezeri (Torrent salamander).
(Wilk
and Raphael 2002).
- One metamorphosed
Dicamptodon copei (Cope's giant salamander) was captured
and 2 others were detected at the Willapa Hills site. (Wilk
and Raphael 2002).
- The invertebrates
that live in temporary waters have a flexible life cycle, exhibiting
temperature-linked development, possession of a diapausing or otherwise
protected egg, and high powers of dispersal (Williams
1996).
- Ephemeroptera,
Hemiptera, Coleoptera, Trichoptera and
Diptera are abundant in temporary waters. The diversity of
invertebrates is lower in temporary waters than in perennial waters
(Williams
1996).
- Invertebrate faunas
inhabiting these temporary streams belong to three groups: permanent
stream faunas with a wide range of tolerance, facultative species,
and specialized temporary stream faunas restricted to this type of
habitat (Williams
and Hynes, 1977).
- Precipitation, infiltration
rate, and substrate play a significant role when discussing the ecology
of temporary streams. The groundwater table can move up or down in
response to recharge. It is controlled by sudden precipitation, consequent
overland flow and/or interflow. When the groundwater table recedes,
the pools will vanish due to evaporation (Williams
and Hynes 1977).
|
|